If you’re nosy like me, sometimes you meet someone at work or in a social situation where there is something unusual about them, something that you don’t know much about but would like to. And then you want to ask a lot of personal questions to help you better understand this person. (Ok, so maybe you just want to ask because you’re nosy, like me. But work with me here.)
As an example, the first time I met someone with AIDS I wanted to ask things like “How do you think you got it?” and “How did you feel when you got the test results?” Luckily I do possess just the tiniest shred of tact, and I usually refrain from probing too deeply – at least until I’ve had a chance to know the person long enough to form some sort of bond. At which point I get comfortable enough to pull out the thumbscrews and start my own little Spanish Inquisition.
Despite my fondness for posing personal questions, I am sometimes less fond of answering them. For instance, I am always taken a little by surprise when I become friends with a straight person and they start asking me questions about my oh-so-exotic gayness. I don’t know why these questions would bother or even surprise me, considering how damn nosy I am about everyone else’s private information. My discomfort may stem from the fact that my life seems normal to me — and it’s jarring to realize suddenly that someone I know finds my situation odd or difficult.
At work I end up meeting a lot of straight people who don’t know many gay people, if they know any at all. They are usually the ones with the questions – the first one always being “When did you realize you were gay?”
I always struggle with this question because I don’t have a clear answer. And why should I? Sexual orientation – and I’m talking overall orientation, not just gay, straight or bi – is something that is unique to each individual, and, when you get down to it, cannot be placed neatly into a little box with a label stuck on it. How am I supposed to know when I “realized” what I was, when the “what” is not even all that easy to define?
Occasionally I’ve heard that the suggested retort to such a question should be “Well, when did you know you were straight?” Although I wholly appreciate the spirit of this response, being a lover of all things sarcastic, I don’t find the response entirely fitting – because when discussing growing up gay vs. growing up straight we’re comparing apples to oranges.
But just to amuse ourselves, let’s start there anyway. When do most people realize they are straight?
Maybe they realize it from the minute they are born, when their parents, families, friends and entire communities start imprinting upon them the notion that their lives will consist of growing into adolescence, finding mates of the opposite gender, falling deeply in love with said mates, marrying them and making babies.
People who in their hearts want to follow the formula outlined above never have their orientation put into question. There is no AHA! moment for these people, no sudden realization of what their general sexual orientation is. They are born with their default “straight” buttons already activated and no one has to ask them when this all occurred. The question is meaningless.
Just as the question so often posed to me seems meaningless. Or if not meaningless, so fraught with complications and nuances that the question becomes unanswerable. And therefore meaningless – at least to me.
If we gays of a certain generation (meaning those of us born before the early 1980s) had been given the information we needed – which is that some people are gay, some are straight, and some are somewhere in-between – we might have grown up better equipped to answer the “When did you realize you were gay?” question. But that’s not the way it happened.
What we have instead are the generations of gay people, those of us born any time before the early 1980s, who had to negotiate the usual torture and confusion of adolescence with the added burden of having no validation or acknowledgment of who we were.
A bit much to throw at a 13-year-old kid, if you ask me. Which is why I find the “When did you realize you were gay?” question particularly troublesome and complicated, if not downright offensive when you really start to think about it.
When did I realize I was gay? Which of the terrifying moments of my childhood and adolescence should I pinpoint and mark as the final AHA! moment that seems so important to you? Was it the moment my older brother started calling me “fag” before I even knew what that was? Was it the moment I noticed Tom B. in the hallway of my junior high and was inexplicably drawn to want to be his friend? Was it the moment I rode an elevator with my schoolmates and members of a gay men’s chorus, who upon exiting were mocked by my classmates? (“Don’t scratch your butts anyone, you’ll get AIDS!”) Was it the moment I thought for the first time there might be no future to my life except AIDS, discrimination and loneliness? Or was it the moment I realized everyone in the entire world was probably going to hate me?
The short answer is, I don’t know and I don’t really give a shit. Just leave me the fuck alone and quit asking about it as if it’s a question you could even begin to understand. And now that I’ve thought this through, maybe I’ll think twice before launching any future Spanish Inquisitions of my own.
Love and coasters,
CP
